Keep the Land, Give Me Peace

Dear Queenie,

Why do Caribbean families always seem to end up fighting over land? My mother is the eldest of several siblings, and there is family property that has never been properly divided. Over the years, she has become the person handling most of the responsibilities connected to it. She makes the calls. She deals with paperwork. She follows up on things. And many times, when money has to be paid for something, she is the one who puts her hand in her pocket. But when it comes to deciding what should happen with the property, suddenly everybody has an opinion. Some siblings want to sell. Some absolutely do not. Some seem to believe they should get more than everybody else. Others question decisions while contributing very little towards the actual work or expenses. Everybody wants a say, but somehow my mother gets the headache. It is becoming stressful for her. There are phone calls, arguments, accusations and old family grievances being dragged into conversations that are supposed to be about property. I am reaching the point where I want to tell my mother to simply give up her claim. We don't need the land. If walking away from her share means she can stop dealing with all of this, I would rather see her enjoy her life than spend the next several years fighting with brothers and sisters over property. But I also wonder whether I have the right to advise her to give up something that belongs to her. Maybe she would regret it later. Maybe my siblings or I would regret it. I just hate seeing what it is doing to her. Why does family land so often become the thing that tears families apart? —Keep the Land, Give Me Peace

Dear Keep the Land, Give Me Peace,

If Caribbean families received a dollar every time somebody said, “But Grandpa said this piece was for me,” we might finally have enough money to settle all the estates. Family land has a way of collecting old grievances along with property. Suddenly the argument isn't only about selling. It's about who paid, who didn't, who looked after the parents, who went abroad, who got more and who was always the favourite. But I would be careful about advising your mother to simply give up her share. There is a difference between deciding something isn't worth fighting over and surrendering something of value because other people have made dealing with it unbearable. Before she gives up any rights, she should know exactly what she owns and get proper independent advice about what walking away would mean. There is also a third option: “she can keep her claim and give up the job.” She can tell her siblings: “I am no longer managing this property by myself. Decisions, expenses and responsibilities will have to be shared.” Then she needs to stop automatically paying bills, chasing paperwork and solving problems simply because nobody else does. Being the eldest doesn't make her the family property manager. If, once she has stepped back from the drama, she decides she truly would rather sell or relinquish her share, that's different. Then she is choosing peace rather than being exhausted into surrender. And don't worry too much about whether you or your siblings “need” the property. It belongs to your mother. She may keep it, sell it, leave it to you, or sell it and spend the money enjoying herself. The land may be an inheritance. The stress doesn't have to be. —Queenie

The Daily Herald

Copyright © 2025 All copyrights on articles and/or content of The Caribbean Herald N.V. dba The Daily Herald are reserved.


Without permission of The Daily Herald no copyrighted content may be used by anyone.

Comodo SSL
mastercard.png
visa.png

Hosted by

SiteGround
© 2026 The Daily Herald. All Rights Reserved.