People take part in a march to improve healthcare benefits in San Juan, Puerto Rico, on November 5, 2015. (Reuters/Alvin Baez)
WASHINGTON, DC--On Monday, the United States (US) Supreme Court agreed to decide the legality of a decades-old congressional decision to exclude Puerto Rico from a federal programme that provides benefits to low-income elderly, blind and disabled people.
The justices took up a US government appeal originally filed by Republican former President Donald Trump’s administration of a lower court ruling that found the exclusion unlawful.
Many Puerto Ricans have long complained that the Caribbean island’s residents are treated worse than other Americans, despite being US citizens. Puerto Rico, which is not a state, is the most-populous of the US territories, with about 3 million people.
Last year, the Boston-based 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favour of a Puerto Rican resident named Jose Luis Vaello-Madero who had previously received Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits when he lived in New York but lost eligibility when he moved to Puerto Rico in 2013.
The 1st circuit decided that Puerto Rico’s exclusion from the programme violated a provision of the US Constitution that requires that laws apply equally to everyone.
Vaello-Madero, who is 66 years old and disabled, mounted his constitutional challenge after the government sued him in federal court in Washington in 2017, seeking more than US $28,000 for payments it had made to him after he moved to Puerto Rico.
SSI benefits are available to any US citizen living in any of the 50 states, Washington, D.C., and the Northern Mariana Islands, but not the territories of Puerto Rico, the US Virgin Islands or Guam.
The decision not to include Puerto Rico was made by Congress when it enacted the programme in 1972. The Justice Department, in urging justices to hear government’s appeal, said the Supreme Court had twice previously upheld the programme.
Puerto Ricans are eligible for a different programme, called Aid to the Aged, Blind and Disabled, that allows for more local control but not as much federal funding, the Justice Department said in court papers.
After Democratic President Joe Biden took office in January, some religious groups urged his administration to drop the appeal.
Puerto Rico asked the Supreme Court to uphold the 1st Circuit ruling. “United States citizens who reside in Puerto Rico enjoy much lesser rights than those who reside in the States, merely because of Puerto Rico’s status as a territory,” Puerto Rico’s government said in court papers. “This inequality is both unconstitutional and unacceptable.”
The court is likely to hear and decide the case in its next term, which starts in October and ends in June 2022. ~ Reuters ~
