Paid My Share, Lost My Wine

Dear Queenie,

A group of us recently had a gathering at a friend's house. We decided to cater the food rather than make the host responsible for cooking. The cost was divided among everyone, and our friend was very efficient about making sure we all paid our share. Some people also brought bottles of wine and other drinks to add to what was available. We had a lovely time. Then the evening ended and things became...interesting. There was quite a bit of food left over. As we started talking about dividing it up, our host immediately said she needed to make a plate for her husband. Her husband had not attended the gathering and had not contributed towards the catering. She packed him a very healthy plate. I thought it was a little cheeky, but fine. She hosted us in her home, so perhaps that's an unofficial hosting benefit. Then I noticed the wine. Several unopened bottles were left, including bottles different people had brought. Instead of asking whether anyone wanted to take one, our host started gathering them together and putting them away. Apparently, all unopened wine had now become part of the house inventory. Nobody said anything. There was just that moment where several of us looked at each other and clearly had the same thought. The woman who had been very particular about everyone contributing equally was suddenly operating under: "What's left in my house stays in my house." I don't care enough about a bottle of wine to start an argument. But I did find the principle irritating. If we're splitting costs so precisely, shouldn't we also be reasonably fair about what's left? Or does hosting mean you automatically inherit the food and bar? —Paid My Share, Lost My Wine

Dear Paid My Share,

Ah. Your gathering began as a cooperative and ended as an acquisition. Your friend was apparently committed to collective ownership right up until the assets needed distributing. Let's separate the two issues. Making a plate for her husband doesn't strike Queenie as outrageous. She hosted the gathering. People used her home, her electricity, her bathroom, probably her ice, garbage bags, serving utensils and whatever else nobody thinks about when they arrive ready to eat. Unless she packed enough catering to feed him until Christmas, a plate for the husband seems like a reasonable unofficial host benefit. The wine is different. If Maria arrived carrying a bottle of wine for everyone to drink, she may well consider it contributed to the gathering and not expect to take it home. But that doesn't automatically mean the host should quietly collect all unopened bottles as payment for services rendered. The graceful thing would have been: "There are a few unopened bottles left. Does anyone want to take back what they brought?" Some people would probably have said: "No, keep it." And then everybody goes home happy. The irritation comes from the contrast you noticed. Your friend was meticulous when fairness required you to contribute, but considerably more relaxed when fairness might require her to share. That tends to bother people more than the actual value involved. Would I confront her now? No. A retrospective wine audit will make everyone look ridiculous. But I would remember it for next time. If she hosts again and everyone is contributing, establish beforehand what happens to substantial leftovers. Or bring exactly what you expect the group to consume. And if you bring a particularly nice bottle that remains unopened, there is nothing rude about saying as you're leaving: "Since we didn't open this one, I'll take it back." Then pick it up. No committee meeting required. Because if we're going to practise strict accounting at dinner, Queenie believes the accounting department should remain open until all assets have been distributed. —Queenie

The Daily Herald

Copyright © 2025 All copyrights on articles and/or content of The Caribbean Herald N.V. dba The Daily Herald are reserved.


Without permission of The Daily Herald no copyrighted content may be used by anyone.

Comodo SSL
mastercard.png
visa.png

Hosted by

SiteGround
© 2026 The Daily Herald. All Rights Reserved.