Let Them Eat Cake

Dear Queenie,

We have a colleague who has somehow become the unofficial custodian of all office birthday cakes. Nobody appointed her. There was no election. But whenever somebody has a birthday and cake appears in the staff room, she takes charge. She cuts it. She decides how big the pieces should be. She announces that everyone should get some before anybody takes seconds. All reasonable so far. The problem is that she remembers who ate. You can walk into the kitchen two hours later, see that there’s plenty of cake left and reach for another piece. From across the room: “You had already.” Queenie, I know. I was there. One colleague recently tried to take a second piece and she told him: “Some people haven’t gotten yet.” Those people weren’t even at work! Are we preserving cake for colleagues who are on vacation? Sometimes there is still cake sitting there at the end of the day, getting dry, while apparently nobody is permitted to have seconds because Sharon from Finance hasn’t collected her piece. Then comes the next stage. She starts wrapping pieces and putting names on them. I once opened the office refrigerator and found six slices of birthday cake individually allocated like government parcels. If somebody brings cake specifically for the office, surely once everyone present has had a reasonable chance, the remainder is fair game? I am an adult with a job. Why am I sneaking towards leftover cake while checking whether another adult is watching me? —Let Them Eat Cake

Dear Let Them Eat Cake,

Every workplace has unofficial positions. Someone becomes responsible for ordering lunch. Someone always knows how the printer works. And apparently your office has appointed a Director of Cake Distribution and Compliance. To be fair, her original principle isn’t unreasonable. If twelve people are sharing a cake, Kevin should not take his fourth slice while three colleagues are still wondering whether there was a birthday. But there is a point at which fairness becomes enforcement. Once everyone who is actually present has been offered cake, Queenie believes the restrictions can begin to relax. People who are expected back shortly? Save them a piece. Someone in a meeting? Certainly. Sharon on annual leave in Curaçao? Sharon has made her choice. What makes this funny is that all of you are apparently obeying her. Who gave her jurisdiction? If there is plenty left and you’ve already had one piece, simply ask: “Has everyone who wants cake gotten some? If so, I’m taking another.” Not: “May I?” You are not applying for a permit. And if she says: “You had already,” you can cheerfully respond: “Yes. It was excellent.” Then proceed according to whatever normal office etiquette allows. No need for a rebellion. No secret cake-eating in the stairwell. Just stop treating an unofficial rule as legislation. Of course, use some common sense. If the birthday person hasn’t had a slice yet, leave the cake alone. If only one piece remains, don’t inhale it at 9:12am before anyone else arrives. And if you personally ate half the cake, Queenie will represent your colleague at the disciplinary hearing. But six individually labelled slices ageing in the refrigerator? No. Birthday cake is supposed to bring joy. It should not require inventory management, ration cards and a sign-out sheet. And if the cake is still there tomorrow? All restrictions are lifted. At that point, you’re not stealing someone’s portion. You’re performing waste management. —Queenie

The Daily Herald

Copyright © 2025 All copyrights on articles and/or content of The Caribbean Herald N.V. dba The Daily Herald are reserved.


Without permission of The Daily Herald no copyrighted content may be used by anyone.

Comodo SSL
mastercard.png
visa.png

Hosted by

SiteGround
© 2026 The Daily Herald. All Rights Reserved.