The Best Super Bowl
St. Maarten continues to shine as one of the Caribbean’s top destinations for food, fun, and sports entertainment. From lively sports bars and beachfront hangouts to award-winning comfort food you can enjoy at home, the island offers something for every taste and every kind of night out including Super Bowl. Maybe you are planning an evening around the big game, or prefer a relaxed dinner with friends, inviting friends to your place, or want to watch the game beachside at sunset with a frozen cocktail. Our Best of 2025 winners might help you develop your plans and make your game day fun and tasty!
St. Maarten’s #1 Sports Bar and a Top Dinner/Entertainment Spot
When it comes to the ultimate sports bar dining experience in St. Maarten, Pineapple Pete stands firmly at number one. Widely regarded as the best sports bar on the island, Pineapple Pete delivers the perfect mix of high-energy sports action, outstanding food, and a lively Caribbean atmosphere that keeps guests coming back again and again. This is not just a place to watch the game it’s a full dining experience. Pineapple Pete’s diverse menu makes it an excellent choice for dinner, whether you’re settling in for a big match-up or simply enjoying a night out. From juicy burgers and fresh seafood to crowd favourites like jerk chicken wings and even sushi, there’s something to satisfy every craving. Pair your meal with ice-cold beers or expertly mixed cocktails, and you’ve got all the ingredients for a great night.
Sports fans love Pineapple Pete for its extensive live sports coverage, but beyond the screens, the venue offers multiple pool tables, the largest arcade and gaming room on the island, and a new VIP pool room extension that adds even more excitement. With live music, non-stop sports, and an electric vibe, Pineapple Pete is the go-to spot to eat, drink, and unwind day or night, and especially on Super Bowl Sunday!
Replay at Simpson Bay Resort: Super Bowl Sunday Done Right
Replay at Simpson Bay Resort is another standout option. Recently voted #2 Best Sports Bar on the island in The Daily Herald Best of 2025, Replay has built a strong reputation among sports lovers. Add in #1 Best Bartender Ziggy, and you know the service is just as impressive as the game-day atmosphere. Replay features an all-you-can-eat buffet for US $56 per person.
Staying In? Best Pizza to Order
If your game-day plan involves staying home, gathering friends, and watching from the couch, there’s no better choice than Domino’s Pizza, officially voted Best Pizza on the island in The Daily Herald Best Of 2025. With locations in Philipsburg and Cole Bay, Domino’s continues to win hearts with consistently delicious pizzas, fast service, and reliable quality. From classic pepperoni and ham to Italian sausage, beef, and fresh vegetables, every pizza delivers flavour you can count on. Add sides like cheesy bread, boneless chicken, and wings, and you’ve got an easy, satisfying feast for Super Bowl this year!
Best Place to pre-order Sandwiches
For quick bites done right, Carl & Son’s remains an island institution. Named Best Place for a Sandwich, this iconic bakery has been serving the community since 1982. Cut out the workload this Sunday, pre-order some sandwiches to slice up and share. From classic turkey and cheese, salami, club, roast beef, and tuna sandwiches to local favourites like turkey, egg & cheese and ham & eggs, Carl & Son’s offers something for everyone. Choose their famous Johnny cakes stuffed with cheese, chicken, bacon, eggs, saltfish, tuna, and turkey to twist your Super Bowl into a Caribbean party. With convenient locations on Pondfill, in Cole Bay, and inside the St. Maarten Medical Center, Carl & Son’s makes it easy to enjoy fresh, affordable, award-winning sandwiches any day of the week.
Best Beach Bar Vibes
For those who prefer their food and drinks with sand between their toes, Buccaneer Beach Bar once again takes the title of Best Beach Bar, plus #2 Best Bar/Happy Hour. Located on Kim Sha Beach in Pelican Key, Buccaneer offers a relaxed, family-friendly, welcoming vibe paired with great food, beach chairs and umbrellas, live music, a fireball on the beach, an ice cream bus, and stunning sunset views. Another great option for beach vibes for the game is Mary’s Boon Beach Bar and Resort.
Best Beer Brand on the Island
Rounding out the Best of 2025 winners is Heineken, named Best Beer Brand of St. Maarten/St. Martin. Recognised worldwide by its iconic green bottle, Heineken remains a staple at bars, restaurants, and events across the island. Beyond the beer itself, Heineken plays a major role in island life as the title sponsor of the legendary St. Maarten Heineken Regatta, now in its 46th year. A tight runner up in second place was Corona, also a great option for your Caribbean Super Bowl celebrations! Carib Beer in third place is a real Caribbean beer, if you haven’t tried it yet, we recommend you do so ASAP. Just be sure to grab an ice cold bucket of your favourite brand wherever you go!
From Pineapple Pete’s unmatched sports bar energy and dinner-worthy menu, to Replay’s Super Bowl-ready setup, Domino’s award-winning pizza, Carl & Son’s iconic sandwiches, Buccaneer’s beachside fun, and Heineken’s island-wide presence, St. Maarten’s Best of 2025 winners showcase exactly why dining and entertainment here are second to none. Enjoy the Big Game!
