By Marcha Woudstra, Roos-Marie van der Heide, and Michelle van Duin of HBN Law & Tax
Introduction
A building permit is required for almost all construction projects. Applications can be submitted to the Minister of Housing, Spatial Planning, Environment, and Infrastructure (“VROMI”). VROMI assesses whether any of the legal grounds for refusal set out in Article 22 of the Building and Housing Regulations (AB 2013, GT no. 144; “Bwv”) apply. For instance, a permit must be refused if the building plan conflicts with the zoning regulations of a development plan. In this blog, we will discuss whether a building permit can be refused due to conflict with the zoning regulations of a draft development plan.
The exhaustive and mandatory system in Article 22 of the Bwv
Article 22 of the Bwv lists the grounds on which an application for a building permit may be refused. For instance, paragraph 5 includes as a ground for refusal “that the building or part of the building will, due to its location or construction, disfigure the surroundings or cause nuisance or a fire hazard to the surroundings.” Paragraph 7 includes as a ground for refusal that “the building plan is contrary to the zoning regulations of a development plan.”
Article 22 is based on a restrictive-imperative system. This means that VROMI must assess whether one or more of these grounds apply to the building application. If so, the building permit must be denied. If not, the building permit must be granted.
VROMI is therefore not authorized to refuse a building permit on other grounds, or to grant a building permit if a ground for refusal does exist. The purpose of this exhaustive and mandatory system is to ensure legal certainty and prevent arbitrariness. Citizens must be able to rely on the fact that a building permit application will be assessed in accordance with the grounds for refusal set forth in Article 22 of the Bwv.
Assessment against the regulations in a draft development plan
The legal certainty that the restrictive and mandatory system is intended to provide is being undermined by uncertainty about the assessment of building permit applications against zoning regulations in draft development plans.
As early as 2014, various draft development plans were drawn up and made available for public inspection. However, these drafts were never adopted as development plans within the meaning of the National Ordinance on the Principles of Spatial Development Planning (“Lvgro”). A building plan that conflicts with such a draft is therefore not in violation of the zoning regulations of a development plan as referred to in Article 22, paragraph 7, of the Bwv. This has also been confirmed in case law. [1]
In our earlier blog post from January 2025, we wrote about what a development plan is and noted that the VROMI had announced at that time that it was preparing a new development plan for the entire island of Sint Maarten. The preliminary draft of this new development plan was expected in the summer of 2026, but we are not yet aware of any such draft. On October 7, 2026, Minister Gumbs reiterated that the adoption of development plans is on the agenda, and he announced a call for proposals to establish a development plan for Sint Maarten. We are not there yet. At this time, therefore, only the draft development plans from 2014 are available.
Recent developments
In a few recent cases, VROMI has taken the position that a construction plan “disfigures the surroundings” or “causes nuisance” to the surroundings because it deviates from the zoning regulations of a draft development plan. This position is not based on the seventh paragraph of Article 22, but on the fifth paragraph of Article 22. As a result, the zoning regulations of a draft development plan indirectly become decisive after all in the decision-making process regarding the granting of permits. This raises the question – particularly in light of the exhaustive and mandatory system – of whether this is legally permissible.
In three rulings by the Court of First Instance of Sint Maarten, it was held that this is indeed permissible. [2] According to the Court, since 2014, VROMI has used the zoning regulations of a draft development plan to assess whether a building “disfigures the surroundings” or “causes nuisance” under Article 22, paragraph 5, of the Bwv. The Court characterizes this policy as a consistent practice, and deviating from it without justification actually undermines legal certainty. In light of this, a draft development plan is a policy document that must be taken into account when assessing whether a building for which a permit has been requested will be a nuisance or eyesore to the surrounding area, according to the Court.
On appeal, the Court of Appeal revised this ruling because no consistent policy had been demonstrated. [3] The Court of Appeal first reaffirmed that a draft development plan is not a statutory provision against which a building permit application must be assessed. The Court of Appeal then confirmed that VROMI may apply a consistent policy when interpreting “disfigures the surroundings” or “causes nuisance”, which could, for example, consist of applying certain rules from a draft development plan, thereby allowing such a plan to have practical significance. However, according to the Court of Appeal, VROMI has not demonstrated that such a consistent policy exists. VROMI will therefore have to assess on a case-by-case basis whether a building plan “disfigures the surroundings” or “causes nuisance”, and cannot rely solely on the finding that a building plan violates a standard from a draft development plan, even though that standard may be given significance, the Court ruled.
Critical comment
We offer a critical comment on this development and question whether this method of assessment fits within the exhaustive and mandatory system of Article 22 of the Bwv. There is, in fact, a fundamental difference between the ground for refusal “contravention of zoning provisions of a development plan” and the ground for refusal “disfigures the surroundings or causes nuisance.”
It can be objectively determined whether a building plan conflicts with zoning regulations. The building plan either complies or it does not. In the former case, the building permit must be granted; in the latter, it must be denied. There is no room for further assessment or weighing of interests.
Whether a building is unsightly or a nuisance to the surrounding area cannot be determined objectively. “Disfiguring” and “nuisance” are open-ended criteria, and VROMI has discretion in interpreting them. Only if, in VROMI’s opinion, unsightliness or a nuisance occurs in a specific case must the building permit be denied.
Although VROMI may apply policy guidelines in interpreting the open standards, it is essential that it remain within the boundaries of the exhaustive-mandatory system. Policy rules may provide guidance but must not result in a test that leaves no room for deviation. Unlike objective provisions in a development plan, deviations from policy are both possible and permissible, provided they are properly justified. [4]
Disguised assessment of zoning regulations in a draft development plan
Using the draft development plan – with its objective zoning regulations – to assess the subjective standards of “disfiguring” and “nuisance” blurs the distinction between the two legal frameworks. This results in a disguised assessment of zoning regulations in a draft development plan, even though the draft development plan lacks the required legal status for such an assessment.
This is problematic in light of the exhaustive and mandatory system, in which only the grounds for refusing a building permit listed in Article 22 of the Bwv may lead to the refusal of a building permit.
In this context, the question arises as to whether legal certainty is truly served by using the zoning regulations of a draft development plan when interpreting a subjective open-ended standard. The terms “disfiguring” and “nuisance” require further interpretation and do not entail an automatic assessment against zoning regulations in a draft development plan. An applicant cannot foresee that a draft development plan will become decisive in this way when assessing a building permit application. This conflicts with the nature and purpose of the exhaustive-mandatory system.
This is all the more relevant because the draft development plans were never adopted in accordance with the Lvgro. During the period in which a draft development plan is available for inspection, Article 22a of the Bwv requires the suspension of building permit applications. This means that building permit applications that are not in accordance with the available draft development plan must be suspended. The obligation to suspend applications applies until the statutory period for adopting a draft development plan under the Lvgro has expired. By doing so, the legislature itself has already indicated that a draft development plan that has not been adopted in time is irrelevant to the assessment of building permit applications. In that light, it is particularly remarkable that a draft development plan from 2014 – which was not adopted in a timely manner – is being used as a framework for assessing a building permit application.
Finally, work is underway on a new development plan for the entire island, which is intended to reflect the most up-to-date spatial planning insights. For this reason as well, the use of an outdated and never-adopted draft development plan as an assessment criterion does not make sense from a policy perspective.
How can we help?
The use of draft development plans when evaluating applications against open criteria such as “disfiguring the surroundings” or “causes nuisance” leads to uncertainty regarding the review of a building permit application. Are you dealing with a building permit that has been denied or, conversely, granted with reference to a draft development plan? Or would you like to know what your legal position is regarding ongoing proceedings or a planned development? Our team has extensive experience in land-use planning and construction law. We’d be happy to work with you to find a solution.
Contact: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
[1] Court of Appeal HLAR, September 17, 2020, ECLI:NL:OGHACMB:2020:229.
[2] Court of First Instance Sint Maarten January 26, 2026, ECLI:NL:OGEAM:2026:16, Court of First Instance Sint Maarten June 30, 2025, ECLI:NL:OGEAM:2025:42, and Court of First Instance Sint Maarten April 28, 2025, ECLI:NL:OGEAM:2025:17.
[3] Court of Appeal HLAR, July 22, 2026, ECLI:NL:OGHACMB:2026:200.
[4] See, for example, a ruling by the Court on the building guidelines in the Hillside Policy and the reasons for deviating from them. Court of Appeal HLAR September 17, 2020, ECLI:NL:OGHACMB:2020:229.





